Wednesday 26 September 2012

GE 13TH, REFERENDUM ON CHIEF MINISTERS





By : SELVARAJA SOMIAH

ELECTIONS to 3 state assemblies in Penang, Malacca and Sabah will be turned into a sort of referendum on the performance of the chief ministers. Whereas Sarawak had its state assembly elections in 2011, meaning Taib Mahmud would still be around past GE13 despite Premier Najib Tun Razak having told the people of Sarawak that he would ensureTaib steps down after the 2011 state election.

Taib is unlikely to retire anytime soon as his Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu (PBB) won all the 35 seats it contested in 2011. Besides, Sarawak has 31 parliamentary seats and Taib controls at least 25 of them.

In all these states, the incumbent chief ministers are very popular and, as a result, the election campaigns will be strongly focused on their performance. As a result, national leaders of both the Barisan National and the Pakatan Rakyat have begun to realize that they actually have little role to play in these elections.

Penang’s one-term chief minister Lim Guan Eng​, Sabah’s two-termed chief minister Musa Aman and Sarawak’s four-termed chief minister Taib Mahmud alongside relatively the low-profile three-termed Chief Minister of Malacca Mohd ​Ali Rustam, respectively, have all acquired a larger-than-life image in their states, making it difficult for opposition parties to easily dislodge them.

This has then given respective ruling parties in all these states an incumbency advantage. Whether all these chief ministers will succeed in their re-election bid will depend on whether they can overcome issues at the constituency level, especially in terms of candidates who don’t have strong track records. But it is increasingly clear to me that the chief ministers have put their parties in a strong position.

Many Malaysian voters have begun choosing governments not on the basis of party ideology and long-prevailing preferences but on specific party leaders. This trend has become more obvious with an increasing number of young people emerging as a major voting bloc. That’s because, in general, party loyalty and party identification among the youth is weaker compared with older Malaysian voters. Perhaps the youth have realized that it is better to focus on leaders rather than parties as there are good and bad leaders in all parties.

People are craving for leaders who are honest, easily accessible and have a strong, pro-rural and pro-people orientation. Incumbent chief ministers of the latest poll-bound states don’t necessarily have all these qualities. Yet, overall, they have performed remarkably well on these attributes; this is what makes it difficult for their challengers. I am not suggesting that these leaders could win without the backing and cadre of their parties. But they have added an extra element of strength and give an edge to their parties. Elections in Malaysia are increasingly focused on a specific leader is clear from recent electoral victories of Taib Mahmud in Sarawak, contributed hugely to his party’s victory.

In the case of Malacca, Mohd Ali Rustam, was barred from contesting in the UMNO elections, the UMNO Disclipinary Board found Mohd Ali guilty of violating party ethics for indulging in money politics and hence was prohibited from contesting the post of UMNO deputy president.

But he still remains as the Malacca Chief Minister. In the past, it was only national leaders such as Dr Mahathir​ and Anwar Ibrahim​, and some regional icons such as Musa Aman, Pairin Kitingan and Taib Mahmud​, who had the magnetism to win on their sheer personal strength. Today, a number of chief ministers, such as Musa Aman and Lim Guan Eng, in these poll-bound states, have acquired this larger-than-party persona.




What is interesting is that all these chief ministers have emerged mainly due to their pro-development agenda. Most of them have implemented welfare-oriented and populist programmes to woo the electorate.

Financial assistance schemes targeting the poor as well as rapid strides in basic infrastructure such as roads and bridges especially in Sabah have all been priorities for the respective chief ministers. These smart chief ministers have found a way of potentially overcoming the dreaded anti-incumbency factor so prevalent in Malaysian elections.

What this suggests is that parties ought to announce leaders in every state, especially those in the opposition, and let these leaders build up a profile. UMNO is benefiting in Sabah due to the image of Musa Aman as an urbane, decent and efficient chief minister.

The recent visit to Sabah by Wu Bangguo, member of the Standing Committee of the Political Bureau of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China and even the visit by Duke and Duchess of Cambridge, Prince William and his wife Cathrine, all confirms that Musa has done a fantastic job in Sabah. Its a fact Sabah is the most successful state in Malaysia in attracting private investments.

For the first quarter of 2012, Sabah under Musa Aman managed to attract private investments in the amount of RM10 billion, way ahead of other states. Among the reasons is having a stable, business friendly and a prudent government besides the environment in Sabah is well protected because of Sabah’s stringent forestry laws and strong conservation programme.

Yet, the party’s’ dogged refusal to announce its chief ministerial candidates in other states, even where popular leaders are available and willing, is going against the voters’ tendency to choose leaders over parties.

Given the voter fixation with state issues and chief ministers, national issues have become rather irrelevant in these elections. Altantuya, Scorpene submarines, Sharizat’s 250million “Lembu” episode and price rise on food items, which the Pakatan hoped to raise in these elections in a big way, appear to have failed to take off as these elections have become virtual referenda on the performance of the chief ministers.

If the UMNO/Barisan National fares poorly in Penang in this coming GE13, it will be mainly due to its inability to challenge the DAP’s popular chief minister Lim Guan Eng and not necessarily to the Barisan National government’s failures in managing the economy or maintaining internal security.

So, even if it fails to win in the Pakatan-ruled states, this is a message that may bring solace to the Barisan National leadership and hopes in national elections to the Parliament that are due in March/April 2013.

20 comments:

  1. Auditor General Tan Sri Ambrin Buang said
    Sabah continues to be among states with an excellent financial management record and can be a role model to other states.

    CM Musa Aman said we should not be easily satisfied or comfortable with the achievement thus far. What's important is that we continue to enhance our efforts to enable this achievement to be maintained and enhanced so as to support the various development activities at all levels.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Untuk menjadi seorang pemimpin bukannya mudah. terlalu banyak masa urusan rasmi berbanding dengan urusan bersama keluarga. Mereka terus berusaha demi memastikan kepentingan rakyat dapat diperjuangkan.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Teruskan menyokong Kerajaan yang benar-benar untuk kepentingan rakyat Sabah. Kerajaan BN adalah pilihan yang terbaik untuk kita.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sabah now has 926,638 registered voters, according to Election Commission (EC) deputy chairman Datuk Wira Wan Ahmad Wan Omar.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think the BN members have done their parts in welcoming GE.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Don't be worried too much. They know what their strategies are.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The Parliamentary Select Committee (PSC) on electoral reform will recommend establishing a permanent committee to assist the Election Commission (EC) to study the electoral roll.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Bahang pilihanraya umum ke 13 (PRU-13) semakin hampir dan telah dirasai oleh semua pihak, terutama sekali ahli-ahli politik, sama ada parti-parti menyokong kerajaan mahupun parti-parti pembangkang.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Musa mendapat sokongan padu daripada para pemimpin yang mempunyai perjuangan yang sama dengan beliau .

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sokongan parti komponen untuk perjuangan di PRU13 amat diperlukan.

      Delete
  10. pada tahun 2003 kadar kemiskinan Sabah berada di atas 24 peratus, kadar itu berjaya diturunkan dan kini kadar kemiskinan hanya 15 peratus. semua ini adalah usaha Musa Aman.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Kadar kemiskinan ini akan terus turun, apabila projek-projek membasmi kemiskinan seperti Jelapang Padi, Agropolitan, PIOC dan Sabah
    Development Corridor siap dan berjalan sepenuhnya.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Projek mega seperti projek Baja di Siptiang, projek minyak dan gas di Kimanis serta Kota Belud, akan menyumbang peluang pekerjaan kepada rakyat Sabah.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Rakyat sendiri juga harus usaha untuk membaiki taraf hidup. Banyak peluang masih ada di Sabah.

      Delete
  13. semenjak Musa menerajui Sabah, lonjakan perekonomian terus meningkat. Simpanan negeri memecah rekod sehingga RM3bilion, bajet negeri juga mencipta rekod di mana untuk pertama kali melepasi angka RM4bilion.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Bujet 2013 harus diurus dengan bijak untuk perkembangan yang berlanjutan di Sabah.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Sabah, under the leadership of Chief Minister Datuk Seri Musa Aman, is among the states with excellent financial management record.. the state’s financial management has improved over the last few years following the responsiveness of government departments and agencies to the demand of financial governance.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Sabah has proven that excellence in financial management is not impossible if (one) serious in implementing them. For certain, Sabah’s success can be a role model or benchmark for other government departments and agencies..

    ReplyDelete