By : AMDEE SIDIK
WHEN we talk about SAPP, it isn’t all about Yong Teck Lee alone; but it involves the entire organisation, Joe Fernandez should learn how to write like an adult instead of spraying it like bullets all over the place.
Let me just briefly respond to him, I'm referring to his article ‘Party dogged by irrelevance’ appeared in FMT18/01/2012.
What grad grind has he with Yong Teck Lee I wouldn’t know, I’m just confining to something I knew.
This material isn't organised to answer item by item of Fernandez’ allegations, and readers are cautioned Fernandez isn’t new writing like he did, Malaysiakini paid a hefty amount due to his malicious writing which led to his sacking not so long ago. Therefore, it doesn’t require rebuttal but suffice to say he does have problem in understanding others.
SAPP has been consistently bringing up issues of unfair treatment by the federal government to Sabah, among the highlights, we asked for Royal Commission of Inquiry of Illegal Immigrants in Sabah, we asked for the increase of Petroleum royalty, we asked for change of cabotage policy and many more.
Its SAPP which brought these issues up, later picked up by others, even by BN component parties-no other political parties as energetic as SAPP in Sabah, but what is seen today very many of our leaders from other political parties, out jealousy are dwarfing SAPP leaders’ ability.
Unfair treatment by the federal government to the States of Sabah continues to exist in many shapes and forms, for example, a new Mykad holders originally not Sabahans are treated by the government of the day far better than the natives of Sabah.
Compare those live in urban areas with those live in the interior, new Sabahans get accessed to facilities, like medical services by virtue they’re living in city or towns but less or not at all in some parts of rural areas.
Batu Sapi by election was the yardstick to measure of the failure of SAPP according to Joe Fernandez, if he can be analytical enough in looking for faults I would think he could also capable to strike the balance of fair reporting
Population of Sabah voters in Batu Sapi is very much different compare with other areas in Sabah namely in the West Coast and Interior.
Illegal immigrants and those obtained Mykad under project UMNO are rest assured wouldn’t vote for SAPP that is known, they are the fixed deposit of UMNO and the MyKad is the key. The UMNO politicians would just say this..vote opposition we’ll take back the MyKad; and that would be enough to torture them with sleepless nights.
I found a 58-year lady Sabahan hasn’t yet got a Mykad to date in Sipitang, whilst the new arrivals got as easy as buying pisang goreng. No Sabahans would want to be robbed their statehood arbitrarily yet it happened.
As one of the leaders in SAPP, though rather new both in the party and in politics I wouldn’t like to hear cheap accusation by a disparate writer whose writing but malicious in nature-I can only think he is also seen willing to being prostitute used by someone to defame others.
SAPP’s friendly approach to its fellow local opposition’s political parties including PR, is well intended, the very idea is to topple BN-UMNO, if only all oppositions can solidify among themselves there would be a greater chance of getting rid of UMNO, any disagreements should be best keep aside and sort out later.
SAPP has many new leaders who now play a dominant role in shaping the party. Many new ideas have been injected to the party to make it very relevant today in contrary to what Fernandez said.
One such idea, which is lauded by SAPP, is Malaysia should have gone away with communal or racial politics mentality led by UMNO. Sabahans by far is more tolerance when come to deal with race and religion; we don’t need to exhume the dead just because some are confused about his religious belief.
Any decision for the party isn't entirely from the President, in my little experience with the party ever since I joined three years ago, no single person dominates party decision-making. Thus Fernandez shouldn’t shut his mind if he were to understand better about Sabahans’ culture.
Looking at the current mood all over the world, Federal government can’t effort not to heed to people’s want; they (the government of the day) can be as stubborn as stubborn can be, but if the price doesn’t come soon it will be later.
Fernandez thought highly of DAP, let me say this DAP is born in urban areas with urban make up, they have zero agenda for kampongs, their struggle isn’t designed for rural people, little do they know what Sabah rural’s dreams, therefore no need to be rhetoric about it. Its ability in Sabah has a ceiling and is still a long way to form Sabah Sate government by its entirety, unlike SAPP a local and non-communal political party.
Let others be the judge.
Walaupun penulisan Fernandez lebih kasar sikit, tapi dia pun ada hak untuk mengemukakan pendapatnya sendiri. Terpulanglah kepada pembaca sama ada mereka setuju ataupun tidak.
ReplyDeleteya.. ia hnya keluarkan pendapatnya.. pembaca hnya perlu bijak menilainya.
DeleteBear in mind our democracy is not as same as those in the UK or USA. Freedom expression is regulated for a purpose which is to keep matters of sensitivity under wrapped. Some of us has not forgotten the dark tragedy of our young nation's democracy which is known as 'tragedi 13 Mei'.
DeleteYTL sendiri pernah mengeluarkan pendapat dengan kasar juga.
DeleteInilah sikap yang ada dengan SAPP.. Bila sendiri yang kena mula marah sana sini. Tapi selalu buat seperti ini kepada orang lain. Sedarlah diri itu dulu sebelum memarahi orang lain.
DeleteKita selalu ingin memperjuangkan kebebasan bersuara, tapi bila ada yang menyuarakan sesuatu yang tidak disetujui, kita pula mengkritik. Tapi harap mereka yang menyuarakan pendapat janganlah melampaui batas.
ReplyDeleteThat's the problem with us Malaysians in general. We take criticism too personally. Even if those criticism is constructive by it's nature. Why can't we just 'agree to disagree' for the betterment of our nation?
DeleteThe mentality needs to change.
Deletewalau macam mana pun semua bergantung pada rakyat.
ReplyDeletejadi, YTL nak buat apa dengan JF ni? mahu saman?
ReplyDeleteSAPP bukannya parti yang sesuai untuk Sabah. Kerana tidak ada pendirian seperti STAR yang diketuai oleh JK.
ReplyDeleteWe can't control what others want to say about us.
ReplyDeleteinikah ciri2 pemimpin yang kononnya berjuang untuk menyuburkan kebebasan bersuara di negara ini?? bila kena batang hidung sendiri, tanpa berfikir panjang terus melenting menyalahkan penulis dengan melemparkan pelbagai bentuk penghinaan.. entah apa akan jadi kepada penulis ini jika pembangkang yang memegang tampuk pemerintahan negara hari ini..
ReplyDelete